Anomaly Research · November 2026
The Cost of Exposure
Identity is privilege. Privacy is paramount.
Not everyone needs to know your name. Most of the services that ask for your email address don’t need that either. They need to recognise you when you come back.
Every place that holds your personal details is one more place they can leak from, be sold from or be used against you. This brief sets out what that costs, in public figures from law enforcement, regulators and courts, and makes the case for a simple principle: fewer places.
PDF edition
Published by Anomaly. Every figure links to its source. Evidence last reviewed 11 November 2026.
Losses reported to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center in 2025, across 1,008,597 complaints. Up 26% in a year.
FBI IC3, 2025People affected by the 2017 Equifax breach. 145.5 million Social Security numbers were exposed.
US Federal Trade Commission, 2019Penalty a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay in October 2026, after a jury found it had misled users about privacy. Meta has said it will appeal.
Court ruling, reported 21 October 202601
One address, everywhere
Your email address was meant to be somewhere to send you mail. It became the way almost every service on the internet identifies you. Sign up for a newsletter, a food delivery app and a bank, and all three now hold the same identifier, usually next to your name and often your phone number.
That makes those details worth far more than a place to send mail. A leaked list with your name and address on it tells a fraudster who to write to and what to call you. A marketing database can be matched against another one because the same address appears in both. And when you want to leave a service, the one thing you can’t take back is that it knows who you are.
This brief is about that ordinary data: the name, email address and phone number you hand over to get through a sign-up form. Profiles assembled later from browsing, location and inference are a separate problem. This one starts earlier, at the moment a service decides what it needs to know in order to let you in.
My Social Security number was among those exposed through Equifax. I can’t change it the way I’d change a password, and I never found out where it ended up. That is what exposure means in practice: it has no end date.
Founder, Anomaly
02
What it costs
People
In the United States alone, people and businesses reported $20.9 billion in losses to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center in 2025, up from $16.6 billion the year before. That is only what was reported, to one agency, in one country.
Phishing and spoofing was the most reported crime, with 191,561 complaints. It works because the sender already has what they need to reach you and sound familiar: an address, and often a name. Complaints fell slightly over two years. The money lost to them did not.
Two neighbouring categories in the same report show where it leads. Personal data breaches accounted for 67,456 complaints and $1.31 billion in reported losses. Business email compromise, in which someone impersonates a colleague or supplier, accounted for $3.05 billion.
Reported losses to phishing and spoofing
US dollars, by calendar year
View as table
| Year | Complaints | Reported losses |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 298,878 | $18,728,550 |
| 2024 | 193,407 | $70,013,036 |
| 2025 | 191,561 | $215,843,126 |
Businesses
For the organisation that loses the data, the bill has several parts: working out what happened, containing it, telling the people affected, and the business that goes elsewhere afterwards. IBM’s annual study of breached organisations put the average cost at $4.99 million in 2026, the highest it has recorded.
In the Middle East, where Anomaly is based, the same study put the average at $8 million. The largest share was lost business: customers and revenue that left after the breach.
These are averages across the organisations IBM studied, most of them large. They are not a forecast for any one company. They do show that the cost of holding personal data is real and rising, and that most of it arrives after the incident is over.
Average cost of a data breach
US dollars, global, by report year
Where an $8 million breach goes
Average cost in the Middle East, US dollars, 2026
03
It doesn’t end with the incident
A breach is reported once. Its effects keep arriving. The details that leak are the ones that make the next approach convincing: a message that uses your name, mentions a company you really deal with, and reaches the address you really use.
Equifax is the clearest case. In 2017 it exposed the records of about 147 million people, including 145.5 million Social Security numbers. Most of them had never chosen to give Equifax anything. The company agreed to pay at least $575 million. The numbers that leaked are still the same numbers.
Australia’s privacy regulator asks people about this directly. In its 2026 national survey, 77% of those whose data had been caught in a breach said they had suffered at least one kind of harm. The most common was more scams and spam.
After a breach
Australians whose data was involved in one, 2026
04
No hack required
Much of the damage involves no intruder at all. The company you gave your details to uses them in a way you were told it wouldn’t, or passes them to someone you never dealt with. Regulators and courts have been pricing that conduct for years, and the prices are going up.
United States
Facebook and Cambridge Analytica
The Federal Trade Commission settled charges that Facebook had deceived users “about their ability to control the privacy of their personal information”, after data on millions of users reached the political consultancy Cambridge Analytica. At the time it was the largest privacy penalty ever imposed. FTC
New Mexico
Meta
A judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury found it had misled users about privacy, counting more than 43 million violations of the state’s Unfair Practices Act. Meta has said it will appeal. Two months earlier, 48 other states had settled related claims for $18 billion. PBS, Axios
France
Fnac Darty
The French regulator CNIL fined two Fnac Darty companies for placing trackers in the Fnac mobile app without consent, including collecting browsing history to drive recommendations. CNIL
California
Disney
California’s attorney general settled allegations that opting out on Disney’s streaming services stopped the sale and sharing of data only on that one service, and often only on that one device. It is the state’s largest privacy settlement so far. IAPP
United States
General Motors and OnStar
The FTC finalised an order settling allegations that GM collected drivers’ precise location and driving behaviour and sold it without their informed consent. FTC
A fine measures what an authority could prove and chose to charge. It says little about what the people involved lost. In every one of these cases, though, the company held something it could misuse.
05
What people say they want
People are not confused about this. Asked whether they have control over how their information is collected and used, 78% of Australian adults said very little or none. In the United States, 73% told Pew Research the same about the data companies collect.
They are also specific about what would make collection acceptable. The top answers are not about trust or brand. They are about limits: a clear purpose, a real choice, and taking only what is needed.
When is collecting personal information acceptable?
Share of Australian adults choosing each condition, 2026
of Australian adults say they have very little or no real control over how their information is collected and used.
OAIC, 2026 · 1,504 adultsof US adults say they have little or no control over the data companies collect about them.
Pew Research Center, 2023 · 5,101 adults06
What they are asked for
A clear purpose, a real choice, and only what is needed. To see how that compares with practice, Anomaly looked at the sign-up screens of 50 widely used consumer services on 14 November 2026: five in each of ten categories, from shopping and food delivery to news, games and banking.
48 of the 50 asked for personal information at the first step. Only 7 of them are the kind of service the law requires to know who its customer is: banks, payment firms and patient-record portals.
96% ask who you are.
Only 14% have to.
50 consumer services, sign-up screens as seen on 14 November 2026
●Asks for personal information 48 of 50 · 96%●of which the law requires it 7 of 50 · 14%○Third-party sign-in or passkey only 2 of 50
Retail and marketplaces
●Amazon●Temu●AliExpress●Samsung●eBay
Food delivery
●DoorDash●Uber Eats●Domino’s●Instacart●Wolt
Streaming
●YouTube●Netflix●Twitch●Spotify●Dailymotion
Social media
●Facebook●Instagram●Reddit●X●WhatsApp
News and publishing
●MSN●Yahoo●Globo●BBC●The Guardian
Travel and transport
●Booking.com●Trip.com●Tripadvisor●Agoda●GetYourGuide
Banking and payments
●PayPal●Wise●Chase●Capital One●American Express
Health and fitness
●Cleveland Clinic●Mayo Clinic○Healthline●Drugs.com●WebMD
Productivity and software
●ChatGPT●GitHub●Canva●Adobe●Zoom
Gaming
○Poki●Xbox●Nexus Mods●CrazyGames●Nintendo
Someone else’s key
The commonest alternative to typing in your details is to sign in through a company that already has them. 35 of the 50 services offered Google sign-in and 29 offered Apple. That saves a password. It usually passes your email address or name along anyway, and it tells the provider where you have an account.
A passkey, which proves you are the same person without saying who that is, was offered by 3 of the 50.
Sign-in options seen
Number of the 50 services showing each option
See what each of the 50 sign-up screens asks for
What each sign-up screen asks for
50 consumer services, first visible sign-up step, 14 November 2026
| Asks for | Sign-in options seen | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phone | Name | Birth date | Address | Other | Password | Passkey | Apple | ||||
| Retail and marketplaces | |||||||||||
| Amazon | A | A | |||||||||
| Temu | A | A | ● | ● | ● | ||||||
| AliExpress | A | A | ● | ● | ● | ● | |||||
| Samsung | S | ● | |||||||||
| eBay | R | R | ● | ● | ● | ● | |||||
| Food delivery | |||||||||||
| DoorDash | S | S | S | ● | ● | ● | ● | ||||
| Uber Eats | A | A | ● | ● | |||||||
| Domino’s | R | R | R | ● | |||||||
| Instacart | A | A | ● | ● | |||||||
| Wolt | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Streaming | |||||||||||
| YouTube | S | ● | |||||||||
| Netflix | S | ● | |||||||||
| Twitch | A | A | ● | ● | |||||||
| Spotify | R | ● | ● | ||||||||
| Dailymotion | S | ● | |||||||||
| Social media | |||||||||||
| A | A | S | S | ● | |||||||
| A | A | S | S | ● | ● | ||||||
| A | A | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| X | R | ● | ● | ||||||||
| R | |||||||||||
| News and publishing | |||||||||||
| MSN | S | ● | ● | ||||||||
| Yahoo | A | R | A | ● | ● | ||||||
| Globo | R | R | R | ● | ● | ||||||
| BBC | R | ||||||||||
| The Guardian | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Travel and transport | |||||||||||
| Booking.com | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Trip.com | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Tripadvisor | S | S | ● | ● | |||||||
| Agoda | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| GetYourGuide | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Banking and payments | |||||||||||
| PayPal | S | ||||||||||
| Wise | S | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | |||||
| Chase | A | ||||||||||
| Capital One | R | ● | |||||||||
| American Express | S | ||||||||||
| Health and fitness | |||||||||||
| Cleveland Clinic | A | A | |||||||||
| Mayo Clinic | S | ● | |||||||||
| Healthline | ● | ● | |||||||||
| Drugs.com | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| WebMD | S | S | ● | ● | ● | ● | |||||
| Productivity and software | |||||||||||
| ChatGPT | A | A | ● | ● | |||||||
| GitHub | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Canva | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Adobe | S | ● | ● | ● | ● | ||||||
| Zoom | S | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Gaming | |||||||||||
| Poki | ● | ● | ● | ||||||||
| Xbox | R | ||||||||||
| Nexus Mods | R | ● | |||||||||
| CrazyGames | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
| Nintendo | R | ● | ● | ● | |||||||
R marked as required A one of two alternatives, such as email or phone S shown, not marked as required not shown at the steps seen ● option seen
“Other” is an age band or birth year, country of residence, or an existing card number.
These are sign-up screens, seen once, on one day. They show what is asked for. They do not show what is kept, shared or lost. But the pattern is plain: the request is nearly universal, and the obligation behind it is rare.
The alternative
Is there a better way?
The rest of this brief argues that there is: a principle, an order followed from account to doorstep, five questions for anyone who runs a sign-up form, and what Anomaly is building.
07
Fewer places
A service can’t leak, sell or misuse what it never had. That is the whole argument, and it turns a privacy problem into a design decision that is made once, at sign-up.
The US National Institute of Standards and Technology has language for it. Its privacy engineering work names a property called disassociability, and its digital identity guidelines describe an identifier made for one service only. NIST also studies how people actually use these protections, with the stated aim of making privacy mechanisms usable enough that people can protect themselves.
Put plainly, three rules follow.
Recognise, don’t identify. A service needs to know you are the same person who came yesterday. It rarely needs to know who that person is.
One identity per service. If each service knows you by a different identifier, a leak from one says nothing about your account at another.
Nothing to phish. A passkey is tied to the real site and never typed, so there is no password to be talked out of.
None of this makes a service’s own database safe, and it doesn’t reach the data a service gathers after you’re in. It means there is less of you in it to begin with.
DisassociabilityEnabling the processing of personal information or events without association to individuals or devices beyond the operational requirements of the system.NIST SP 800-63-4, glossary
Pairwise pseudonymous identifierA pseudonymous identifier generated by an IdP for use at a specific RP.In plain terms: a sign-in provider gives each service its own identifier for you. NIST SP 800-63-4, glossary
Usable privacyWe conduct research with an end goal of improving the usability of privacy mechanisms so that people are better able to protect their sensitive information online.NIST, Human-Centered Cybersecurity
08
An order with no name
A delivery is the hardest everyday case for the argument in this brief. Something physical has to reach a real person, and money has to change hands. If that can happen without the shop knowing who you are, a name on a sign-up form is hard to defend anywhere.
It can. Every step below is already in everyday use somewhere. Nobody has had a reason to put the steps together.
-
01
An alias
You open an account as inspired_heron_48 and sign in with a passkey. The shop can recognise you next time. It holds no name, email address or phone number.
-
02
A prepaid payment
You pay with a gift card, or in cash at the door. The shop learns that the order is paid for. It never sees a bank card, or the name on one.
-
03
A place
You choose where: a parcel locker, a lobby, a street corner. A three-word location or an open Plus Code pins it to a few metres, with no street address and no resident attached.
-
04
A code
The shop gives you a one-time code. The courier hands the parcel to whoever presents it. The courier learns a place and a code, and nothing about who collected.
-
05
Afterwards
The receipt, the refund and any complaint belong to the alias and the order number. Nothing in the record says who you are.
The shop
An alias, what was ordered, and that it was paid for.
Your name, email address, phone number or home address.
Whoever takes the payment
A valid gift card, or cash.
Who is paying.
The courier
A place and a code.
Who the parcel is for.
Where this stops
This is not invisibility. Choose your own front door as the place and you have told the courier where you live, however the location is written. Your phone and your network leave traces that no order form controls.
Some orders do need more. A parcel crossing a border needs a named recipient for customs. Alcohol or medicine needs proof of age or a prescription at the door. Each is one fact, asked for at one moment, by the one party that needs it.
What it shows
Few people will want to shop this way. But the order arrives. The name, email address and mobile number on a sign-up form are things the service chose to ask for, and the delivery would have happened without them.
09
If you run a sign-up form
Everything so far is written from the side of the person filling in the form. The decision sits on the other side, with whoever designs it. Every field you ask for becomes a record you have to store, secure, account for and one day delete.
Read from that side, the evidence in this brief is a list of liabilities. In IBM’s Middle East figures, the largest share of a breach’s cost is the customers who leave afterwards. The penalties in section 04 were for how data was used, not for losing it. And the phishing that follows a leak is aimed at your customers, often in your name.
Five questions are worth asking of every field.
Do we need this to let the person in? Recognising someone who comes back takes an identifier. It rarely takes an identity.
Could it be different here from everywhere else? An identifier that exists only at your service is worth nothing in someone else’s breach, and theirs is worth nothing in yours.
What is it for, and have we said so? A clear and specific purpose is the condition people most often set for handing anything over.
How long do we keep it? Data you no longer hold can’t leak. About half of Australian adults (52%) name strong limits on retention as a condition for collection.
What happens to our customers if it leaks? The details in your database are the ones that make the next message to them convincing.
Bionic, in the next section, is Anomaly’s answer to the first two.
Lost business: the largest share of an $8 million average breach in the Middle East. Customers and revenue that left afterwards.
IBM Middle East, 2026of Australian adults say a clear and specific purpose makes collection acceptable. Only 44% say a trustworthy organisation does.
OAIC, 2026The largest penalty in this brief involved no intruder. It was for misleading users about what was done with data the company already held. Under appeal.
Court ruling, reported 21 October 202610 · From Anomaly
Bionic starts at sign-in
Bionic is how Anomaly puts those three rules into practice. You sign in with a passkey. Each service you use gets its own identity for you: an alias and an identifier that mean nothing anywhere else. The service can recognise you every time you return. It never receives your email address.
It works today. Paradox, Anomaly’s AI workspace, signs people in with Bionic. Opening it to other apps is the work in progress, and signed communications, so that a message from a business can be verified before it is trusted, come after that.
A typical sign-up holds
- Name
- your full name
- you@yourdomain.com
- Phone
- +971 •• ••• ••••
- Secret
- a password
The same details, at every service.
With Bionic, the service holds
- Alias
- quiet-heron
- ID
- bnc_7f3a…e21
Illustrative. Different at every service, and nothing to phish.
11
Sources and method
Each figure keeps the scope its source gave it. The FBI numbers are complaints and self-reported losses. The IBM numbers are averages across the organisations it studied. The survey numbers describe the people surveyed. They measure different things and are not added together here.
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report. Total complaints and losses; phishing/spoofing, personal data breach and business email compromise by year. Figures read from the report’s tables.
- US Federal Trade Commission, Equifax to pay $575 million as part of settlement, 22 July 2019.
- US Federal Trade Commission, FTC imposes $5 billion penalty and sweeping new privacy restrictions on Facebook, 24 July 2019.
- PBS NewsHour, Meta must pay New Mexico $25 billion, 21 October 2026. Violation count as disclosed in Meta’s quarterly SEC filing.
- Axios, Meta ordered to pay $25 billion over Cambridge Analytica privacy scandal, 21 October 2026.
- IBM, Cost of a Data Breach Report 2026. 602 organisations; breaches between March 2025 and February 2026. Earlier years from the 2024 and 2025 editions.
- IBM, Cost of a Data Breach Report 2026: Middle East findings, August 2026.
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Australian Community Attitudes to Privacy Survey 2026. 1,504 adults, fieldwork 16 to 30 March 2026. © Commonwealth of Australia, CC BY 4.0. Charts and shortened labels by Anomaly.
- Pew Research Center, How Americans View Data Privacy, 18 October 2023. 5,101 US adults, May 2023.
- CNIL, Cookies and mobile application: 7 million euros fine against Fnac Darty Participations et Services and Fnac Direct. Decision of 22 October 2026, published 29 October.
- IAPP, California’s attorney general issues largest CCPA fine to date. Settlement announced 11 February 2026.
- US Federal Trade Commission, FTC finalizes order settling allegations that GM and OnStar collected and sold geolocation data, January 2026.
- NIST Special Publication 800-63C-4, Digital Identity Guidelines: Federation and Assertions, glossary.
- NIST, Human-Centered Cybersecurity: privacy research area.
- Anomaly, sign-up screen audit, 14 November 2026. 50 consumer services in ten categories, selected from the public Semrush Top Websites rankings; McDonald’s and The New York Times were replaced by Uber Eats and The Guardian. First visible sign-up step only, observed in three passes on one day. No details were entered and no account was created.
Stay in the loop
New writing. In your Bionic inbox.
Get signed updates when we publish new articles and research. No email address required.
